Game Results

Atlanta Duplicate Bridge Center

6761 Peachtree Industrial Boulevard, Suite 200

Atlanta, Georgia 30360 (770) 248-0306

EVENT>Open Pairs               |SESSION>Saturday Aft |SECTION> A N-S
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>August 18, 2012    |CLUB NO.>113712    | 08/18/2012 16:21
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> Dan Papineau    |RATING>Charity Club Championship    |MOVEMENT>MITCHELL
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   84.0 |TOP>   6 |MP LIMITS>None/2500      |CLUB>Atlanta Duplicate Bridge
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=7/B=5                           ,---,-----------,-------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |  Overall  |      Section      |      |Final    |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-A|Rnk-B| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ ---------
 1 Mary Bray              Rebecca Guberman         B   .     .   |   .     .     75.00  44.64
 2 Paula Kreps            Donald Kreps             B   3     3   |   1     1     99.00  58.93  1.64(OA)
 3 Sanjeev Pathak         Larry Giltman, M.D.      A   4     .   |   2     .     90.00  53.57  1.23(OA)
 4 Kathleen Beatty        Betty McDonald           B   .     .   |   .     .     67.00  39.88
 5 Steven Appel           R Stein                  B   .     .   |   .     .     83.50  49.70
 6 Kish Devaraj           Mike Sheldon             A   5     .   |   3     .     89.00  52.98  0.92(OA)
 7 Carol Watson           Anne Barnwell            B   .     4   |   .     2     84.50  50.30  0.65(OB)

                                          Totals                                588.00


                     **PAIRS**
BOARD     1     2     3     4     5     6     7
  /
   1>     5     1     5     0     3     2     5
         530   100   530    50   170   140   530

   2>     4     3     6     5     1-    0     1-
         300   100  1370   620  -450  -500  -450

   3>     4-    0     4-    1-    4-    4-    1-
         120  -100   120   -50   120   120   -50

   4>     2     4-    4-    0     1     4-    4-
        -170   100   100  -620  -500   100   100

   5>     2     5      -    3-     -    6     3-
        -110   130  -200   100  -200   730   100

   6>     0     5-    5-    2-    2-    2-    2-
        -100   420   420   -50   -50   -50   -50

   7>     6     0     2     4-    4-    2     2
         100  -790  -620  -140  -140  -620  -620

   8>     0     1-    4     1-    3     5-    5-
         -50   150   300   150   180   400   400

   9>     3-    3-    6     3-    0     3-    1
         140   140   420   140   -50   140   110

  10>     4     4     2     6     1     4     0
         650   650   620   990   500   650   200

  11>     3-    6     3-     -    3-    3-     -
        -450  -200  -450  -480  -450  -450  -480

  12>     3-    6     3-     -     -    5     2
        -430    50  -430  -920  -920  -400  -520

  13>     2-    6     2-    0     2-    2-    5
          90   200    90  -100    90    90   130

  14>     2     3-    5-    0     3-    5-    1
          50   100   130  -170   100   130  -140

  15>     0     6     1-    1-    3-    5     3-
        -800   140    50    50   100   110   100

  16>     1-    5-    1-    1-    5-    4     1-
         170   420   170   170   420   200   170

  17>     3-    3-    1     3-    6     0     3-
         510   510   500   510  1010  PASS   510

  18>     4-     -    2     4-    4-     -    4-
         650  -100   620   650   650  -100   650

  19>     1-    4-    3     4-    6     0     1-
        -620  -140  -170  -140   200  -650  -620

  20>     2-    0     1     2-    4     5     6
         100  -200  -140   100   110   200   300

  21>      -    3-    3-    6      -    3-    3-
        -100  1440  1440  1460  -100  1440  1440

  22>     5     1     3-    6     1     1     3-
        -500  -650  -620   200  -650  -650  -620

  23>     2-    2-    0     1     5     4     6
        -200  -200  -800  -300   110  -180   300

  24>     0     6     4-    1     2-    2-    4-
        -500  -100  -120  -430  -400  -400  -120

  25>     1     2-    5     0     5     5     2-
         130   400   430   -50   430   430   400

  26>     0     6     3-    1     3-    3-    3-
         130   230   200   140   200   200   200

  27>     4     6     1-    0     5     3     1-
         -90    90  -110  -120    50  -100  -110

  28>     6     2     3-    5     0     1     3-
          90  -120   -90    50  -200  -180   -90









EVENT>Open Pairs               |SESSION>Saturday Aft |SECTION> A E-W
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>August 18, 2012    |CLUB NO.>113712    | 08/18/2012 16:21
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> Dan Papineau    |RATING>Charity Club Championship    |MOVEMENT>MITCHELL
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   84.0 |TOP>   6 |MP LIMITS>None/2500      |CLUB>Atlanta Duplicate Bridge
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=7/B=4                           ,---,-----------,-------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |  Overall  |      Section      |      |Final    |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-A|Rnk-B| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ ---------
 1 Joan Sheldon           Thomas Laforge           B   .     .   |   .     .     75.00  44.64
 2 Richard Brody          Suzy Taylor              B   .     .   |   .     .     78.50  46.73
 3 Denis Taneri           Ernie Eayrs              A   .     .   |  3/4    .     81.00  48.21  0.43(SA)
 4 Sean Gannon            David Zeckets            B   1     1   |   1     1    101.00  60.12  2.92(OA)
 5 Vinay Apte             Maureen McGuire          A   .     .   |   .     .     72.00  42.86
 6 Lois Keith             Connie Smilowitz         A   .     .   |  3/4    .     81.00  48.21  0.43(SA)
 7 Carole Budnick         Joseph Velardita         B   2     2   |   2     2     99.50  59.23  2.19(OA)

                                          Totals                                588.00


                     **PAIRS**
BOARD     1     2     3     4     5     6     7
  /
   1>     1     3     5     4     1     1     6
        -530  -170  -100  -140  -530  -530   -50

   2>     2     4-    3     6     0     4-    1
        -300   450  -100   500 -1370   450  -620

   3>     1-    1-    6     1-    1-    4-    4-
        -120  -120   100  -120  -120    50    50

   4>     4     5     1-    1-    1-    1-    6
         170   500  -100  -100  -100  -100   620

   5>     5-    1     0     5-    2-    2-    4
         200  -130  -730   200  -100  -100   110

   6>     3-     -    3-     -    3-    3-    6
          50  -420    50  -420    50    50   100

   7>     1-    6     4     4     4     1-    0
         140   790   620   620   620   140  -100

   8>     3     4-     -    2      -    4-    6
        -180  -150  -400  -300  -400  -150    50

   9>     2-    2-    0     5     2-    2-    6
        -140  -140  -420  -110  -140  -140    50

  10>     2     2     4     6     0     2     5
        -650  -650  -620  -200  -990  -650  -500

  11>     0     2-    2-    5-    5-    2-    2-
         200   450   450   480   480   450   450

  12>     0     1     2-    4     5-    2-    5-
         -50   400   430   520   920   430   920

  13>     3-    3-    1     6     3-    3-    0
         -90   -90  -130   100   -90   -90  -200

  14>      -     -    5     6     4     2-    2-
        -130  -130   140   170   -50  -100  -100

  15>     1     4-    2-    4-    6     2-    0
        -110   -50  -100   -50   800  -100  -140

  16>     2     4-    4-    4-    4-     -     -
        -200  -170  -170  -170  -170  -420  -420

  17>     5     2-    2-    2-    0     2-    6
        -500  -510  -510  -510 -1010  -510  PASS

  18>     4     1-    1-    1-    1-    5-    5-
        -620  -650  -650  -650  -650   100   100

  19>     3     4-    1-    4-    0     1-    6
         170   620   140   620  -200   140   650

  20>     5     0     3-    3-    2     6     1
         140  -300  -100  -100  -110   200  -200

  21>     2-    0     5-    5-    2-    2-    2-
       -1440 -1460   100   100 -1440 -1440 -1440

  22>     2-    0     1     5     5     5     2-
         620  -200   500   650   650   650   620

  23>     0     5     3-    1     3-    2     6
        -300   300   200  -110   200   180   800

  24>     1-    5     6     3-    0     3-    1-
         120   430   500   400   100   400   120

  25>     6     5     1     3-    1     1     3-
          50  -130  -430  -400  -430  -430  -400

  26>     5     6     2-    0     2-    2-    2-
        -140  -130  -200  -230  -200  -200  -200

  27>     6     2     1     0     3     4-    4-
         120    90   -50   -90   100   110   110

  28>     1     0     6     4     5     2-    2-
         -50   -90   200   120   180    90    90






Open Pairs, Saturday Aft, August 18, 2012

Board 1
North Deals
None Vul

♠ 7 6
♥ A K J 10 9 8 4
♦ J
♣ 10 6 3

♠ K Q 5 3
♥ 6 3
♦ A 8 6 3
♣ K 8 7

N
W		E
S

♠ A J
♥ 7 5 2
♦ K 10 5 2
♣ J 5 4 2

♠ 10 9 8 4 2
♥ Q
♦ Q 9 7 4
♣ A Q 9

NS 3♥; NS 1N; EW 2♦; EW 1♠; EW 1♣; Par +140

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
3 ♥×	N	3	530		5.00	1.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
3 ♥×	N	3	530		5.00	1.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 5-Apte-McGuire
3 ♥×	N	3	530		5.00	1.00	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 ♥	N	4	170		3.00	3.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 2-Brody-Taylor
3 ♥	N	3	140		2.00	4.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
4 ♣	E	−2	100		1.00	5.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
4 ♦	E	−1	50		0.00	6.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 7-Budnick-Velardita

Board 2
East Deals
N-S Vul

♠ —
♥ K 7 2
♦ 9 7 3 2
♣ A J 6 5 4 3

♠ A Q 10 9 8 2
♥ J 10
♦ J 5 4
♣ K 2

N
W		E
S

♠ K J 7 6 5 4 3
♥ A 9 5
♦ —
♣ 9 8 7

♠ —
♥ Q 8 6 4 3
♦ A K Q 10 8 6
♣ Q 10

NS 6♦; NS 5♥; EW 4♠; NS 5♣; Par +300: EW 6♠×−2

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
6 ♦	N	6	1370		6.00	0.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 5-Apte-McGuire
5 ♦	S	6	620		5.00	1.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
6 ♠×	E	−2	300		4.00	2.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
5 ♠×	E	−1	100		3.00	3.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
5 ♠	W	5		450	1.50	4.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 2-Brody-Taylor
4 ♠	E	5		450	1.50	4.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
6 ♥×	N	−2		500	0.00	6.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets

Board 3
South Deals
E-W Vul

♠ A 5 2
♥ A K 9 7
♦ 8 5
♣ A 8 6 5

♠ K 9 4 3
♥ Q J 5
♦ A 10 6
♣ 9 4 2

N
W		E
S

♠ J 10 8
♥ 8 4 2
♦ K 7 4 3 2
♣ K 10

♠ Q 7 6
♥ 10 6 3
♦ Q J 9
♣ Q J 7 3

NS 1N; W 2♦; NS 2♣; NS 1♠; NS 1♥; E 1♦; Par −90

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
1 NT	N	2	120		4.50	1.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
1 NT	N	2	120		4.50	1.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 5-Apte-McGuire
1 NT	N	2	120		4.50	1.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 2-Brody-Taylor
1 NT	N	2	120		4.50	1.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
2 NT	N	−1		50	1.50	4.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
2 NT	N	−1		50	1.50	4.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 NT	S	−2		100	0.00	6.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs

Board 4
West Deals
Both Vul

♠ Q 4 2
♥ Q 10
♦ A Q J 4
♣ K 8 3 2

♠ A J 10
♥ A J 8 7 4
♦ K 9 3
♣ 7 6

N
W		E
S

♠ K 6
♥ K 5 3 2
♦ 8 6 2
♣ Q J 10 4

♠ 9 8 7 5 3
♥ 9 6
♦ 10 7 5
♣ A 9 5

EW 2♥; EW 1N; NS 1♠; EW 1♦; EW 1♣; Par −110

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
4 ♥	W	−1	100		4.50	1.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
4 ♥	E	−1	100		4.50	1.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 5-Apte-McGuire
3 ♥	E	−1	100		4.50	1.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
3 ♥	W	−1	100		4.50	1.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 ♥	W	4		170	2.00	4.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
4 ♠×	S	−2		500	1.00	5.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 2-Brody-Taylor
4 ♥	W	4		620	0.00	6.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 7-Budnick-Velardita

Board 5
North Deals
N-S Vul

♠ 8 5 2
♥ A 6 5 2
♦ 9 3
♣ 7 4 3 2

♠ 6 4
♥ Q J 9 7
♦ 5
♣ A K J 9 8 5

N
W		E
S

♠ K Q 10 3
♥ 8 3
♦ Q 8 4 2
♣ Q 10 6

♠ A J 9 7
♥ K 10 4
♦ A K J 10 7 6
♣ —

NS 3♠; NS 2♥; NS 3♦; EW 3♣; NS 1N; Par +100: EW 4♣×−1

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
3 ♥×	S	3	730		6.00	0.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
3 ♦	S	4	130		5.00	1.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 2-Brody-Taylor
3 NT	E	−2	100		3.50	2.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 NT	E	−2	100		3.50	2.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 5-Apte-McGuire
3 ♣	W	3		110	2.00	4.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
4 ♦	S	−2		200	0.50	5.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
3 ♦	S	−2		200	0.50	5.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge

Board 6
East Deals
E-W Vul

♠ 10 4
♥ A 10 9 5 4
♦ K J 4 2
♣ K 10

♠ K Q 5
♥ Q J 7 6 3
♦ Q 10 5
♣ J 6

N
W		E
S

♠ 9 8 7
♥ K 2
♦ A 9 8 6
♣ 7 5 4 3

♠ A J 6 3 2
♥ 8
♦ 7 3
♣ A Q 9 8 2

NS 4♠; NS 4♣; NS 2N; NS 1♥; NS 1♦; Par +420

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
4 ♠	S	4	420		5.50	0.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 2-Brody-Taylor
4 ♠	S	4	420		5.50	0.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
3 NT	N	−1		50	2.50	3.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 NT	N	−1		50	2.50	3.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
3 NT	N	−1		50	2.50	3.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
3 NT	S	−1		50	2.50	3.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 5-Apte-McGuire
3 NT	N	−2		100	0.00	6.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 7-Budnick-Velardita

Board 7
South Deals
Both Vul

♠ 9 7 6 2
♥ 3
♦ J 5 4 3 2
♣ 9 8 3

♠ A Q 5 4 3
♥ A 10 7
♦ 8
♣ K 7 4 2

N
W		E
S

♠ K J 10
♥ 9 8 6 4
♦ A K 7 6
♣ 10 6

♠ 8
♥ K Q J 5 2
♦ Q 10 9
♣ A Q J 5

EW 4♠; EW 3N; EW 2♥; EW 1♦; EW 1♣; Par −620

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
4 ♠	W	−1	100		6.00	0.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
2 ♠	W	3		140	4.50	1.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 ♠	E	3		140	4.50	1.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
4 ♠	W	4		620	2.00	4.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
4 ♠	E	4		620	2.00	4.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
4 ♠	W	4		620	2.00	4.00	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 5-Apte-McGuire
4 ♠×	W	4		790	0.00	6.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 2-Brody-Taylor

Board 8
West Deals
None Vul

♠ K Q
♥ A K 9 7
♦ A K 8 2
♣ 6 5 3

♠ A 10 8 6 3
♥ Q
♦ Q 4 3
♣ Q 10 9 8

N
W		E
S

♠ 9 7
♥ J 10 6 5 2
♦ 10 9 6
♣ K 7 4

♠ J 5 4 2
♥ 8 4 3
♦ J 7 5
♣ A J 2

NS 2N; S 2♠; S 2♥; S 3♦; N 2♦; N 1♠; N 1♥; NS 1♣; Par +120

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
3 NT	S	3	400		5.50	0.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
3 NT	N	3	400		5.50	0.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 5-Apte-McGuire
2 ♠×	E	−2	300		4.00	2.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
2 NT	N	4	180		3.00	3.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
2 NT	N	3	150		1.50	4.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 2-Brody-Taylor
2 NT	N	3	150		1.50	4.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 NT	N	−1		50	0.00	6.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 7-Budnick-Velardita

Board 9
North Deals
E-W Vul

♠ 7 6
♥ A Q 9 7
♦ 8 4 3 2
♣ A K 2

♠ A Q 4 3
♥ 5
♦ K J 10 5
♣ J 9 4 3

N
W		E
S

♠ J 10 9 5
♥ J 8
♦ A 9 6
♣ Q 8 6 5

♠ K 8 2
♥ K 10 6 4 3 2
♦ Q 7
♣ 10 7

EW 3♠; NS 3♥; EW 4♣; EW 2♦; Par −100: NS 4♥×−1

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
4 ♥	N	4	420		6.00	0.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
2 ♥	S	3	140		3.50	2.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 ♥	S	3	140		3.50	2.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
3 ♥	S	3	140		3.50	2.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 5-Apte-McGuire
3 ♥	S	3	140		3.50	2.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 2-Brody-Taylor
2 ♥	S	2	110		1.00	5.00	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
4 ♥	S	−1		50	0.00	6.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 7-Budnick-Velardita

Board 10
East Deals
Both Vul

♠ K J 8 7 5 4
♥ 10 8 4
♦ 9 5 3
♣ 3

♠ A Q 9 6
♥ 7
♦ A 8 2
♣ J 8 7 6 5

N
W		E
S

♠ 10 3 2
♥ Q 6
♦ Q J 4
♣ K 10 9 4 2

♠ —
♥ A K J 9 5 3 2
♦ K 10 7 6
♣ A Q

NS 5♥; NS 3N; NS 3♦; EW 2♣; NS 1♠; Par +650

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
4 ♥×	S	5	990		6.00	0.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 5-Apte-McGuire
4 ♥	S	5	650		4.00	2.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
5 ♥	S	5	650		4.00	2.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
4 ♥	S	5	650		4.00	2.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 2-Brody-Taylor
4 ♥	N	4	620		2.00	4.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
5 ♣×	E	−2	500		1.00	5.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
4 ♣	E	−2	200		0.00	6.00	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets

Board 11
South Deals
None Vul

♠ K 6
♥ 7 5 4 2
♦ 8 6 3
♣ J 8 5 3

♠ 9 5
♥ Q J 3
♦ 10 9 4
♣ K 10 9 6 2

N
W		E
S

♠ A J 10 7 3 2
♥ A
♦ A K 7
♣ A Q 7

♠ Q 8 4
♥ K 10 9 8 6
♦ Q J 5 2
♣ 4

EW 5N; EW 5♠; EW 4♣; EW 3♦; EW 1♥; Par −460

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
3 ♠	E	5		200	6.00	0.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
4 ♠	E	5		450	3.50	2.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
4 ♠	E	5		450	3.50	2.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
4 ♠	E	5		450	3.50	2.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
5 ♠	E	5		450	3.50	2.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 2-Brody-Taylor
4 ♠	E	6		480	0.50	5.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 5-Apte-McGuire
4 ♠	E	6		480	0.50	5.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets

Board 12
West Deals
N-S Vul

♠ K 8 6
♥ K J 10 8 7 5
♦ 8 6 3 2
♣ —

♠ A 9 2
♥ 2
♦ Q J
♣ A K J 10 9 6 4

N
W		E
S

♠ Q 10 7
♥ A 9 3
♦ A 10 7 4
♣ Q 8 3

♠ J 5 4 3
♥ Q 6 4
♦ K 9 5
♣ 7 5 2

W 6♣; EW 4N; E 5♣; EW 2♠; NS 2♥; W 3♦; E 1♦; Par −920

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
6 ♣	W	−1	50		6.00	0.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
5 ♣	W	5		400	5.00	1.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 2-Brody-Taylor
3 NT	E	4		430	3.50	2.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 NT	E	4		430	3.50	2.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
3 NT	E	7		520	2.00	4.00	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
6 ♣	W	6		920	0.50	5.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 5-Apte-McGuire
6 ♣	W	6		920	0.50	5.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 7-Budnick-Velardita

Board 13
North Deals
Both Vul

♠ Q 8 6 2
♥ K 5 4 3
♦ J 9 7 3
♣ Q

♠ A K 3
♥ A Q 10
♦ 8 5 2
♣ 10 4 3 2

N
W		E
S

♠ J 5 4
♥ 9 8 7 6
♦ 6 4
♣ K J 7 6

♠ 10 9 7
♥ J 2
♦ A K Q 10
♣ A 9 8 5

NS 2♠; NS 3♦; NS 1N; NS 1♥; EW 1♣; Par +110

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
2 ♦	E	−2	200		6.00	0.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
2 ♦	S	4	130		5.00	1.00	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
2 ♦	N	2	90		2.50	3.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 5-Apte-McGuire
1 NT	S	1	90		2.50	3.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 2-Brody-Taylor
1 NT	S	1	90		2.50	3.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
1 NT	S	1	90		2.50	3.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
2 NT	S	−1		100	0.00	6.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets

Board 14
East Deals
None Vul

♠ 9 8 7 6 4
♥ J 10 4
♦ Q 6
♣ K 10 5

♠ K
♥ Q 8 3
♦ J 10 8 7 4 3 2
♣ J 6

N
W		E
S

♠ Q J 10 5 2
♥ A 9 6 5 2
♦ 5
♣ A 9

♠ A 3
♥ K 7
♦ A K 9
♣ Q 8 7 4 3 2

NS 4♣; NS 2N; EW 2♥; EW 2♦; NS 1♠; Par +130

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
4 ♣	S	4	130		5.50	0.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 2-Brody-Taylor
3 ♣	S	4	130		5.50	0.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
4 ♥×	E	−1	100		3.50	2.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
4 ♥	E	−2	100		3.50	2.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 ♥	E	−1	50		2.00	4.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 5-Apte-McGuire
2 ♥	E	3		140	1.00	5.00	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
3 ♥	E	4		170	0.00	6.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets

Board 15
South Deals
N-S Vul

♠ K 9 7 4 3
♥ —
♦ 7 3
♣ A K Q 9 5 2

♠ Q 8 5 2
♥ A 9 8 6
♦ A 8
♣ J 7 3

N
W		E
S

♠ A 10
♥ K Q 7 5
♦ Q J 9 6 2
♣ 10 8

♠ J 6
♥ J 10 4 3 2
♦ K 10 5 4
♣ 6 4

EW 3♥; NS 3♣; EW 1N; W 2♦; NS 1♠; E 1♦; Par −140

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
2 ♠	N	3	140		6.00	0.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
3 ♣	N	3	110		5.00	1.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
2 NT	W	−2	100		3.50	2.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
4 ♥	W	−2	100		3.50	2.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
3 ♦	E	−1	50		1.50	4.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 2-Brody-Taylor
4 ♥	W	−1	50		1.50	4.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
5 ♣×	N	−3		800	0.00	6.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 5-Apte-McGuire

Board 16
West Deals
E-W Vul

♠ Q 8 7 3
♥ A K 8 5 4
♦ 8
♣ K Q 3

♠ 10 2
♥ Q J 6
♦ A Q 5 4 3
♣ 10 7 5

N
W		E
S

♠ K 9 4
♥ 9 2
♦ K 6
♣ A 9 8 6 4 2

♠ A J 6 5
♥ 10 7 3
♦ J 10 9 7 2
♣ J

NS 4♠; NS 4♥; NS 2N; NS 2♦; EW 1♣; Par +420

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
4 ♥	N	4	420		5.50	0.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
4 ♥	N	4	420		5.50	0.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
2 ♥	N	5	200		4.00	2.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
3 ♥	S	4	170		1.50	4.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 5-Apte-McGuire
3 ♠	N	4	170		1.50	4.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 2-Brody-Taylor
3 ♥	N	4	170		1.50	4.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
3 ♥	N	4	170		1.50	4.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs

Board 17
North Deals
None Vul

♠ A K 10 5
♥ 8 4 2
♦ A
♣ A K J 10 8

♠ 9
♥ 10 9 5 3
♦ K Q J 9 7 4
♣ 3 2

N
W		E
S

♠ Q 2
♥ A K 6
♦ 8 6 5 3
♣ 7 6 5 4

♠ J 8 7 6 4 3
♥ Q J 7
♦ 10 2
♣ Q 9

NS 5N; NS 5♠; NS 5♣; EW 2♦; NS 1♥; Par +460

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
6 ♠	S	7	1010		6.00	0.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 5-Apte-McGuire
4 ♠	S	7	510		3.50	2.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
4 ♠	S	7	510		3.50	2.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
4 ♠	S	7	510		3.50	2.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
4 ♠	S	7	510		3.50	2.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 2-Brody-Taylor
5 ♦×	W	−3	500		1.00	5.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
Pass			Pass		0.00	6.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 7-Budnick-Velardita

Board 18
East Deals
N-S Vul

♠ J 10 9
♥ Q J 10 9 7 5
♦ A 4
♣ K 4

♠ K 7 5 4 2
♥ 2
♦ 10 7 6 3
♣ A Q 5

N
W		E
S

♠ 6
♥ K 8
♦ K J 9 5 2
♣ 10 8 7 6 3

♠ A Q 8 3
♥ A 6 4 3
♦ Q 8
♣ J 9 2

NS 4♥; N 3N; S 2N; NS 2♠; W 3♦; E 2♦; EW 2♣; Par +300: W 5♦×−2

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
5 ♥	N	5	650		4.50	1.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
4 ♥	N	5	650		4.50	1.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
4 ♥	N	5	650		4.50	1.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 5-Apte-McGuire
4 ♥	N	5	650		4.50	1.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 2-Brody-Taylor
4 ♥	N	4	620		2.00	4.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
4 ♥	N	−1		100	0.50	5.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
4 ♥	N	−1		100	0.50	5.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 7-Budnick-Velardita

Board 19
South Deals
E-W Vul

♠ 9 6
♥ 7 6 4 2
♦ J 10 6 4
♣ A 6 3

♠ A 4 2
♥ A K J 9 3
♦ K 9 7 2
♣ 7

N
W		E
S

♠ K 10 8 7 5
♥ 10 8 5
♦ —
♣ Q 10 8 5 2

♠ Q J 3
♥ Q
♦ A Q 8 5 3
♣ K J 9 4

EW 4♠; EW 4♥; EW 2N; NS 2♦; EW 1♣; Par −500: NS 5♦×−3

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
4 ♥	W	−2	200		6.00	0.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 5-Apte-McGuire
3 ♥	W	3		140	4.50	1.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 ♥	W	3		140	4.50	1.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
3 ♥	W	4		170	3.00	3.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
4 ♠	W	4		620	1.50	4.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
4 ♠	E	4		620	1.50	4.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 2-Brody-Taylor
4 ♥	E	5		650	0.00	6.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 7-Budnick-Velardita

Board 20
West Deals
Both Vul

♠ Q 10 4 3
♥ Q J 9
♦ K 10 7 6 2
♣ 3

♠ A 7 6 2
♥ K 8 7 6 3 2
♦ 9
♣ 10 2

N
W		E
S

♠ K 9 5
♥ A 5 4
♦ J 8 3
♣ K J 8 5

♠ J 8
♥ 10
♦ A Q 5 4
♣ A Q 9 7 6 4

NS 4♦; S 2N; EW 2♥; N 1N; NS 2♣; Par +130

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
4 ♥	W	−3	300		6.00	0.00	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 2-Brody-Taylor
4 ♥×	E	−1	200		5.00	1.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
2 ♠	N	2	110		4.00	2.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 5-Apte-McGuire
3 ♥	W	−1	100		2.50	3.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
3 ♥	W	−1	100		2.50	3.50	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
2 ♥	W	3		140	1.00	5.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
4 ♦×	N	−1		200	0.00	6.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz

Board 21
North Deals
N-S Vul

♠ K J 5 4 3
♥ 10 7
♦ A K 8
♣ Q 10 4

♠ 10 9 7
♥ 9 5
♦ 7 3
♣ K 9 8 6 5 3

N
W		E
S

♠ Q 6 2
♥ 6 3 2
♦ Q J 10 9 2
♣ 7 2

♠ A 8
♥ A K Q J 8 4
♦ 6 5 4
♣ A J

NS 7♥; NS 6N; S 6♠; N 5♠; NS 3♦; NS 3♣; Par +2210

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
6 ♥	S	7	1460		6.00	0.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 2-Brody-Taylor
6 NT	S	6	1440		3.50	2.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 5-Apte-McGuire
6 NT	N	6	1440		3.50	2.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
6 NT	N	6	1440		3.50	2.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
6 NT	N	6	1440		3.50	2.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
6 ♥	S	−1		100	0.50	5.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
6 NT	N	−1		100	0.50	5.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets

Board 22
East Deals
E-W Vul

♠ Q 4
♥ Q 9 6 4 3
♦ A Q 9 6 3
♣ 4

♠ A 9 6 2
♥ 2
♦ J 8 4
♣ K J 10 7 3

N
W		E
S

♠ K J 5 3
♥ K J
♦ K 10 2
♣ A 9 8 2

♠ 10 8 7
♥ A 10 8 7 5
♦ 7 5
♣ Q 6 5

EW 5♠; EW 4N; EW 5♣; NS 2♥; EW 2♦; Par −650

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
3 NT	E	−2	200		6.00	0.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 2-Brody-Taylor
5 ♥×	S	−3		500	5.00	1.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
4 ♠	E	4		620	3.50	2.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
4 ♠	E	4		620	3.50	2.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
4 ♠	W	5		650	1.00	5.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 5-Apte-McGuire
4 ♠	E	5		650	1.00	5.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
4 ♠	E	5		650	1.00	5.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz

Board 23
South Deals
Both Vul

♠ A K J 10 9 7 6
♥ —
♦ 9 8 6
♣ 10 4 3

♠ 8 4 3 2
♥ 7 2
♦ J 10
♣ A K 9 5 2

N
W		E
S

♠ Q 5
♥ K Q 9 8 4
♦ A K Q
♣ Q 7 6

♠ —
♥ A J 10 6 5 3
♦ 7 5 4 3 2
♣ J 8

E 4N; E 2♥; EW 3♣; Par −630

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
4 ♥	E	−3	300		6.00	0.00	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
2 ♠	N	2	110		5.00	1.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
2 NT	E	4		180	4.00	2.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 ♠×	N	−1		200	2.50	3.50	1-Bray-Guberman vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
3 ♠	N	−2		200	2.50	3.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 5-Apte-McGuire
3 ♥	S	−3		300	1.00	5.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 2-Brody-Taylor
4 ♠×	N	−3		800	0.00	6.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 7-Budnick-Velardita

Board 24
West Deals
None Vul

♠ Q 8 6 4 3 2
♥ 7 6 5 2
♦ K
♣ 6 3

♠ A J 5
♥ 9 3
♦ J 10 8 7
♣ A K 9 5

N
W		E
S

♠ K 10 9 7
♥ K Q 10 4
♦ 6 2
♣ J 8 7

♠ —
♥ A J 8
♦ A Q 9 5 4 3
♣ Q 10 4 2

EW 3N; E 2♣; EW 1♠; E 1♦; W 1♣; Par −400

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
2 ♦×	S	−1		100	6.00	0.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 5-Apte-McGuire
2 NT	W	2		120	4.50	1.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
1 NT	W	2		120	4.50	1.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
3 NT	W	3		400	2.50	3.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
3 NT	W	3		400	2.50	3.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 NT	W	4		430	1.00	5.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 2-Brody-Taylor
3 ♦×	S	−3		500	0.00	6.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs

Board 25
North Deals
E-W Vul

♠ K J 8
♥ 7 5 4 3
♦ A K 7 3
♣ J 3

♠ 7 6
♥ J 10 8 6 2
♦ Q 9
♣ 9 7 5 4

N
W		E
S

♠ A Q 10 9 5 4
♥ Q
♦ 8 5
♣ K 8 6 2

♠ 3 2
♥ A K 9
♦ J 10 6 4 2
♣ A Q 10

NS 4N; N 5♦; S 4♦; N 2♠; NS 2♥; S 1♠; NS 1♣; Par +430

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
3 NT	N	4	430		5.00	1.00	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 NT	N	4	430		5.00	1.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
3 NT	N	4	430		5.00	1.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 5-Apte-McGuire
5 ♦	N	5	400		2.50	3.50	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
5 ♦	N	5	400		2.50	3.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
4 ♦	N	4	130		1.00	5.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 2-Brody-Taylor
5 ♦	N	−1		50	0.00	6.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge

Board 26
East Deals
Both Vul

♠ K 7
♥ 10
♦ A 9 6 5 4 3 2
♣ 9 5 3

♠ 10 8 2
♥ A 8 5 4 3
♦ K
♣ Q 8 7 2

N
W		E
S

♠ 6 3
♥ Q 9 7 6
♦ Q 10
♣ A J 10 6 4

♠ A Q J 9 5 4
♥ K J 2
♦ J 8 7
♣ K

NS 4♠; NS 4♦; EW 2♥; EW 3♣; NS 1N; Par +500: EW 5♣×−2

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
2 ♠	S	6	230		6.00	0.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
2 ♠	S	5	200		3.50	2.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
3 ♥	W	−2	200		3.50	2.50	5-Appel-Stein vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
2 ♠	N	5	200		3.50	2.50	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 5-Apte-McGuire
3 ♣	E	−2	200		3.50	2.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
2 ♠	S	3	140		1.00	5.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
3 ♦	N	4	130		0.00	6.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 2-Brody-Taylor

Board 27
South Deals
None Vul

♠ K 10 8
♥ J 10 7 2
♦ A Q 7
♣ A 8 5

♠ J 9 4 2
♥ A Q
♦ K 10 9
♣ K 7 3 2

N
W		E
S

♠ A 7 6 5
♥ K 8 6 4 3
♦ 8 3
♣ J 6

♠ Q 3
♥ 9 5
♦ J 6 5 4 2
♣ Q 10 9 4

NS 1N; NS 2♦; NS 2♣; EW 1♠; EW 1♥; Par +90

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
2 ♦	S	2	90		6.00	0.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
2 ♥	W	−1	50		5.00	1.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs
1 NT	E	1		90	4.00	2.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 2-Brody-Taylor
3 NT	N	−2		100	3.00	3.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 5-Apte-McGuire
2 ♠	W	2		110	1.50	4.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
2 ♠	W	2		110	1.50	4.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
1 NT	W	2		120	0.00	6.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge

Board 28
West Deals
N-S Vul

♠ J 8 3
♥ A J 5
♦ K 7 6 3
♣ K Q 9

♠ K 9 2
♥ K Q 10 7
♦ A J 9 4
♣ 7 2

N
W		E
S

♠ Q 10 5 4
♥ 3 2
♦ Q 8 2
♣ A 10 4 3

♠ A 7 6
♥ 9 8 6 4
♦ 10 5
♣ J 8 6 5

W 2N; EW 2♠; E 1N; EW 2♦; EW 1♣; Par −120

Contract	By	Made	Scores		Matchpoints		Pairs
			N-S	E-W	N-S	E-W
1 NT	N	1	90		6.00	0.00	1-Bray-Guberman vs 2-Brody-Taylor
2 ♠	E	−1	50		5.00	1.00	4-Beatty-McDonald vs 1-Sheldon-Laforge
1 NT	E	1		90	3.50	2.50	3-Pathak-Giltman, M.D. vs 6-Keith-Smilowitz
1 NT	W	1		90	3.50	2.50	7-Watson-Barnwell vs 7-Budnick-Velardita
1 NT	W	2		120	2.00	4.00	2-Kreps-Kreps vs 4-Gannon-Zeckets
1 NT×	W	1		180	1.00	5.00	6-Devaraj-Sheldon vs 5-Apte-McGuire
2 ♣	S	−2		200	0.00	6.00	5-Appel-Stein vs 3-Taneri-Eayrs